In the wine world, there are pieces of conventional wisdom that have been repeated and burnished until they have reached the status of Gospel.
Unfortunately, many of them aren’t true, but neither are they likely to be challenged anytime soon. Aspiring sommeliers do not readily contradict the people training them, nor do consumers generally feel confident enough to question “experts” in their fields. And so these chestnuts roll on, year after year and generation after generation, acquiring the importance of commandments engraved on stone tablets.
Here are some examples:
Foie gras and Sauternes are one of the perfect food and wine combinations. Actually, they’re a terrible match. Think about it—you’re combining the over-the-top unctuousness of the liver with the over-the-top sweetness of the wine, resulting in a sensory overload without contrast or interest. True, most Sauternes in good vintages will display balancing acidity, but it’s really not enough to create a counterpoint. Even worse, the foie gras/Sauternes course usually appears early on in a dinner, blowing out the palates of diners for the courses to come.
Dessert wine should always be sweeter than the dessert it accompanies. This is nonsense, particularly if one views food and wine pairing as the act of assembling contrasts (as it is today) rather than complementary flavors (as it used to be). A sweet dessert paired with an even sweeter wine seldom produces an edible match. Granted, one of the elements needs to be sweeter than the other, but the sommelier has more choices at his/her disposal than the pastry chef, who is expected to produce something decadent. A rich, sweet dessert can easily be balanced by a wine that is off-dry, moderate in alcohol and brimming with crisp acidity.
Asparagus and wine are natural enemies. Says who? Try a dry Muscat or an unoaked Sauvignon Blanc (Pouilly-Fumé, Sancerre, or something from New Zealand). Or roast the asparagus on a grill, and pair it with a light, chilled red—Beaujolais, Pinot Noir, lightly oaked Sangiovese or Tempranillo. Anyone wishing to pursue this further should investigate the work of Canadian sommelier Francois Chartier; his book, Taste Buds and Molecules, has been called “a groundbreaking work” by none other than Ferran Adria.