NI’s Dining Awards: Best Key Lime Pie

Best Key Lime Pie

Randy’s Paradise Shrimp

Naples Illustrated's Dining Awards - Best Key Lime Pie - Randy's Paradise Shrimp - Best Desserts in Naples

Key lime pie at Randy’s Paradise Shrimp

Photo by Vanessa Rogers

Boxes of Randy’s (239-949-6001) Famous Florida Key Lime Pie fill refrigerators at this Bonita Springs restaurant and gourmet market. You can order it by the slice in the dining room or take home a whole pie to slake your inevitable addiction. It is the paradigm for Key lime pie—a perfect graham cracker crust topped with creamy, fluffy and just-tart-enough filling made fresh daily from Florida’s tiny, round, yellow Key limes. Whipped topping completes the yummy iconic dessert. Whole pies are also available by mail order in two-packs.


Honorable Mention

Truluck’s Seafood, Steak, Crab House

Truluck’s pastry chef makes all the restaurant’s desserts from scratch, and the Key lime pie is no exception. It is served generously and traditional-style, with graham cracker crust and whipped cream. (, 239-530-3131)


For more award winners, click here.

Naples Illustrated's Dining Awards - the best restaurants, dishes and cuisine in Naples, the Paradise Coast and Southwest Florida


Facebook Comments